13 個適合所有年齡段學生的精彩在線辯論遊戲（+30 個主題）

Debates activities are not students’ best candy flavours. They’re like black licorice, tasteless, boring and hard to chew on (which they want to avoid at all cost), and often in the midst of a debate, you can hear the noise of crickets instead of that enthusiastic back-and-forth you’ve always dreamed about.

組織辯論活動並不容易打破常規，但有了這13個互動性很強的 在線辯論遊戲 （離線也能完美工作），教師可以幫助培養一個有趣且引人入勝的學習環境，同時教導學生說服的藝術。

看看如何在線辯論如下！

目錄

• Overview
• #1 – Argument Wars
• #2 – The Republia Times
• #3 – Debatestorming
• #4 – Five good reasons
• #5 – Model United Nations
• #6 – Where do you stand?
• #7 – Desert island
• #8 – Quandary
• #9 – Real or Fake
• #10 – Goose Goose Duck
• #11 – Werewolf
• #12 – Zombie Apocalypse
• #13 – Devil’s advocate
• 30個很好的辯論話題
• 常見問題

Overview

AhaSlides 的更多提示

• 初學者如何辯論
• 學生辯論主題

如何進行有效的在線辯論   

如何進行學生辯論 that is not dry as dust, engages even the least opinionated person, and easily goes with the flow – is a question many teachers contemplate. So buckle up because we’ve got a few secret tricks for your classroom debates:

- 設定具體目標。 課堂辯論的目的是共同進步並探索不同的想法。 確保將您的目標寫在白板上，以便每個人都能記住。

- 來個小回合 破冰船遊戲. It’s vital that the students feel comfortable with their peers to open the door for discussion.

- 有時， 匿名 is what you need to facilitate a smooth debate. Let students submit opinions anonymously, so they don’t feel the fear of judgement from their classmates. 

- 建立一套基本規則:

+ Remind your students that everyone is on the same board, and there’s no right or wrong, nor special treatment.

+ 沒有人身攻擊或使事情變得個人化。

+ 基於非事實證據的論點將被駁回。

+ Prepare to listen and respect every viewpoint, and admit when you realise you’re wrong.

- 玩一些有趣的遊戲 擼起袖子加油吧。 將激烈的辯論變成輕鬆有趣的遊戲，是確保學生玩得開心、辯論過程順利進行的最佳方式。

13 款精彩的學生在線辯論遊戲  

#1 – Argument Wars

Has “become a lawyer” ever been on your bucket list? Because 爭論戰爭 is all about defending and becoming the right hand of justice. This game uses a card game motif to introduce students to the constitutional arguments behind some important historical U.S. Supreme Court cases. The students can choose the side of each case and will have to piece each part of evidence to form a coherent debate and win the judge’s heart.

有九個案例可供探索，因此教師可以將班級分成九個不同的組或對。 每個人將選擇一個特定的案例並一起完成活動。

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– The gameplay mechanism is simple and great for developing a basic understanding of cases and arguments.

– Argument Wars work on multiple platforms: website, iOS, and Android.

#2 – The Republia Times

共和國時報 是一款發生在虛構反烏托邦的免費網頁遊戲。 學生扮演編輯的角色，他必須在出版親政府故事和提供多汁的八卦故事以增加讀者之間取得平衡。

It doesn’t stress the debating element heavily, but rather shows students the art of persuasion and the political nature of each system. Let your students play at their own pace, or play in class to enliven the discussion.

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– It’s completely free and adds extra spice to the class’s 10 minutes break time.

– The students can learn about challenging issues like censorship and use their critical thinking to evaluate their choices to develop the best solution.

#3 – Debatestorming

A minute has passed and no one has said anything. And of course it’s not rocket science to figure out if you just state the question and expect a blazing chit and chat circulating around the class, it often ends with the eerie silence. During these times you can break the cycle with some competitive elements in 辯論風暴?

在這個遊戲中，你將全班分成小組，給大家一個辯論問題。 每個小組都必須寫下他們的意見並在 60 秒內證明該意見的合理性。 哪一組能夠說服觀眾並獲得最多的選票將是獲勝者。

For this activity, you can use AhaSlides’ interactive 頭腦風暴幻燈片 to collect the gang’s opinion in a flash and let students vote for the best team.

團隊合作使 夢想的工作

讓同學們分組集思廣益，通過這個實用的袖珍功能，100% 準備使用🎉，競爭贏得觀眾的心

#4 – Five good reasons

如何在壓力下冷靜應對？ 在 五個好的理由, you will give out a list of prompts such as “Give me five good reasons why students should wear uniforms” or “Give me five good reasons why people love red pandas”. The students, in turn, will have to brainstorm five reasonable ideas in 2 minutes.

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– The idea is not to come up with the most correct answers but to let the students practice flowing in a stressful situation.

– The game is easily adapted in various settings as an ESL debate game, debate game for adults and so much more.

#5 – Model United Nations

We’ve heard about the United Nations everywhere, but do we really know its functions? Model United Nations (MUN) is an educational simulation in which students role-play as delegates from around the world, gathered together to solve a persistent global problem such as climate change, wildlife conservation, human rights, etc.

他們必須準備、提交他們提出的決議，並與其他代表辯論以獲得多數票。

However, don’t let those heavy matters get in your way of breeding a fun, engaging experience. You can let them discuss a sillier topic such as 我們應該有一個國際秘密握手日嗎？ or 我們應該將我們的研究預算用於開發獨角獸嗎？

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– MUN is a great opportunity to let the students gain a deeper understanding of current world issues.

– Your students get to role-play as important figures discussing important topics.

#6 – Where do you stand?

在這個簡單的在線辯論遊戲中，您將辯論雙方分為兩種觀點： 非常同意 強烈反對. 然後你發表聲明，學生將不得不在雙方之間採取立場。 將他們與另一位持相反觀點的學生配對，並要求他們向對方證明他們的選擇是正確的。

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– The game pushes students to form their critical opinion and brainstorm the reasoning behind it, rather than being in the “grey” area.

#7 – Desert island

假設所有學生都被困在一個荒島上，他們會帶什麼三樣東西，為什麼？ 在這個活動中，讓學生提交他們的選擇和推理，然後投票選出最有意義的陳述。 這是一款出色的遠程友好型遊戲，可供團隊一起玩並分享他們的意見。

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– You can get to know your students’ unique characteristics through their choices.

– The game develops students’ ability to come up with creative solutions in specific situations.

#8 – Quandary

作為殖民地的隊長， 困惑 讓學生扮演領軍人物的角色：解決爭端，為居民解決問題，塑造不同星球上新文明的未來。

You can let your students play alone or in pairs, and facilitate group discussion after they’ve finished the game. Ask them thought-provoking questions such as “why did you choose the solution you did?”, or “what could have been done better for the colony?”.

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– Attractive comic art style.

– There’s no right or wrong. The students are in complete control of the decision-making in their colony.

– Supporting materials such as a game guide and help forum are available on the Quandary website.

#9 – Real or Fake

幫助學生培養識別假新聞的能力是每個老師的夢想，而這款遊戲將教會他們不要相信一切。 您可以通過以下簡單步驟組織活動：

- 第一步: 打印出物體的圖片，例如狗。

- 第一步: 把它切成小塊。 確保每一件作品，沒有人可以識別它是什麼。

- 第一步: Split the class into teams of 3. One will be the judge/the guesser, one will be the “truth” debater and one will be the “lie” debater.

- 第一步: Tell the two debaters what the full picture is, then give them a piece of the image you’ve prepared. The “truth” debater will have to make proper claims to the guesser so that he/she can guess the right object, while the “lie” debater will try to claim it is a different thing.

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– The students can practice the art of persuasion and how to judge the evidence based on the information they have collected.

#10 – Goose Goose Duck

鵝鵝鴨 是一款在線社交推理遊戲，您可以在其中扮演傻鵝。 您將不得不與其他鵝夥伴一起完成任務，最重要的是，放逐懷有惡意的混入群中的鴨子。 您的學生將不得不互相智取並證明自己的清白，才能成為最後的學生。

除了所有的火焰和追逐之外，您和您的學生還可以一起探索各種地圖並執行支線任務。 Goose Goose Duck 沒有無聊的餘地，所以開始在電腦或手機上下載它，創建一個房間並邀請每個人馬上玩。

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– Available on both PC and mobile devices, and is completely free.

– Funny character designs that you instantly love, and can customise too.

– A more PG-friendly version of the infamous online game Among Us.

– Your students get to learn how to reason and counterpoint during a debate.

#11 – Werewolf

夜色漆黑，充滿了恐怖。 你能殺死村民中的狼人，還是成為每晚偷偷獵殺的狼人？ 狼人是另一款社交推理遊戲，玩家必須利用他們的說服能力來贏得遊戲。

遊戲有兩個角色：村民和狼人。 每天晚上，村民們都必須確定誰是偽裝成其中一員的狼人，而狼人需要在不被抓住的情況下殺死一名村民。 當村民成功放逐所有狼人時，遊戲結束，反之亦然。

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– The game requires students to practice diverse skills: social skills, teamwork, critical thinking, strategic thought, etc. in order to win.

– You can add more roles and rules to make the game more exciting.

#12 – Zombie Apocalypse

In this scenario, the students all have positions in a community which is the last stand before the zombie apocalypse. There’s a shortage of food and one person will be exiled to balance out the resources. Each student within the group will have to prove the importance of their position in order to stay.

通過此活動，您可以根據您擔任的角色數量將班級分成大組或中組。例如，教師、廚師、音樂家、政治家、記者等。每個人將依次說明為什麼他們非常需要確保他們的位置。

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– Another great online debate game filled with creativity.

– The game fosters students’ quick thinking and rebuttal skill.

#13 – Devil’s advocate

Playing Devil’s advocate is to take the opposite view to a claim just for the sake of argument. Your students don’t have to believe in what they are saying, but rather generate a debate and clarify the issue with an argument. You can let your class practice in pairs or in groups and one student will be assigned as the devil who asks thought-provoking questions.

我們為什麼喜歡它：

– Worrying your students might be too similar to raise their opinions? This game will help you spark debates naturally.

– It helps students understand that initiating a debate is useful to dig deeper into a topic.

有哪些好的辯論話題？ 

Good debate topics should be ‘debatable’ – and by that we mean they should ignite a desire to voice out, and bring different ideas to the front (if the whole class all agree on something it’s not much of a debate!).

以下有30個辯論想法和主題，可以引發熱烈的討論，適合高中辯論和國中辯論。 您可以將這些主題與 最好的數字課堂工具，由 AhaSlides 推薦。

了解更多與我們有關的事情 互動課堂活動 指導！

社會和政治問題辯論話題

– Plastic bags should be banned.

– We should all be vegetarians.

– We shouldn’t have gender-specific bathrooms.

– Countries shouldn’t have borders.

– The world should only have one leader.

– The government should enforce vaccine mandates for all citizens.

– TV should be banned for children under age 6.

– Everyone should ride electric cars.

– Zoos should be banned.

– People who smoke should pay more taxes.

教育辯論話題

– Everyone should wear uniforms to school.

– The grading system needs to be omitted.

– Students in juvenile detention don’t deserve a second chance.

– More budget should be allocated to food quality improvement.

– Students can use mobile phones during classes.

– If the students take online classes, the parents shouldn’t pay any fee.

– Students need to go to university if they want to be successful.

– No one needs to learn advanced math since it is impractical.

– Everyone should learn what they’d like in school.

– Every school should have a park and a playground to be qualified as a school.

有趣的辯論話題

– Tom cat is better than Jerry mouse.

– Hot dogs are sandwiches.

– Having siblings is better than being the only child.

– Every social media platform should add a “dislike” button.

– Kong is better than Godzilla.

– Anime is better than cartoons.

– Students should be rewarded with ice cream for good behaviour.

– Chocolate flavour is better than vanilla flavour.

– Pizza slices should be square.

– Blink is the plural of wink.

常見問題